Opinion: The Pro Cycling Challenge — a challenge indeed
On Tuesday evening at the City Council study session,
the local organizing committee of the USA Pro Cycling Challenge presented their
plans. On Aug. 25, Boulder will be part of the semi-final Stage 6. The stage
course will pass through Boulder in the morning, and then loop through the
mountains, and return via Lee Hill Road, through town, and finish at the
Flagstaff amphitheater. It’s an event with great potential for excitement, but
also with the opportunity for serious problems on Flagstaff because of
extremely limited access and the potential for environmental damage.
Various city, county and other agencies are apparently
hard at work looking at all the issues, from traffic control to fire risks to
emergency access. But the fundamental constraint here is that the Flagstaff
Road area is a “zero failure area;” this is not an event where “we’ll do it
better next time” is acceptable. If there is significant environmental damage,
if there is a fire, if there is an emergency for which evacuation doesn’t run
smoothly, if residents who live above Flagstaff have access problems, if
residents who live at the base have trespassing problems, etc., then this race
will never happen in Boulder again. And those who pushed it will be held
responsible. The good news is that, at least based on my conversations with two
of the organizing committee members, they are well aware of this standard and
say that they intend to live up to it.
It is unclear how many people are likely to want to go
up Flagstaff to watch the finish, but if the number is too large (what that
would be is still to be determined), then the organizers agree that they would
have to limit access. But it is unclear whether that could really be done or
how it should be attempted. However, unlike one council member who thinks that
this is no different than mountain top finishes in Europe, the race organizers
seem to have correctly perceived that this situation requires much more
attention to be paid to not just mitigating the risks, but eliminating them.
Fire is a particular issue in August. As another council
member pointed out, we just had two significant fires around this time. And
dealing with a large crowd that is standing around is a lot different than
dealing with hikers, who are less likely to be smoking or drinking. In addition
to fire trucks, the fire agencies would do well to have people stationed at
close intervals with water tanks on their backs, ready to put out anything that
starts. I would not presume, as I heard one person say at the meeting, that the
race watchers will be well behaved and follow “the rules.” Better safe than
sorry in this case, because all it will take is one fire to create mayhem and
possibly significant loss of life.
One council member brought up a good question, asking how
long will the racers actually be on Flagstaff, from the leader to the last
rider, because that’s how long there will be no possibility for vehicular
access. Given how spread out the Tour de France has been sometimes, the race
organizers might consider a cut-off, so that residents both above and along the
course are not overly inconvenienced.
There were numerous comments about “marketing Boulder”
and “marketing Open Space.” Personally, I dislike the idea of marketing
Boulder’s Open Space. Open Space currently has many millions of visitors a
year, and the budget is already stressed. Perhaps a better message could be to
push for open space programs in other cities, so that the load decreases rather
than increases.
I am glad that the race organizers are soliciting
donations, since I am less than certain that the additional sales tax from the
projected 100,000 visitors will make up for the additional costs to the city.
And just so it’s clear, per Boulder’s city charter, no Open Space money can be
spent on this race.
Final point — it does not work for this to be presented
as a fait accompli. The city manager would do well to allow citizens, from both
in and out of the city, to comment on the arrangements before they are
finalized. This is Boulder, after all.